Excel workbook that reads two pasted reports and outputs a categorised breakdown, how would you build it?
Our take
In the ever-evolving landscape of data management, the integration of automation into everyday tasks is not just a convenience but a necessity—especially in fast-paced environments such as hotel operations. The challenge presented in the article about building an Excel workbook that automates the daily breakfast briefing underscores the ongoing need for innovative solutions that streamline processes and enhance productivity. By cross-referencing two distinct reports and categorizing the data efficiently, this approach exemplifies how even conventional tools like Excel can be transformed into powerful allies in managing complex information. This aligns with broader trends in workplace efficiency, where tasks are becoming increasingly data-driven and automated.
The situation described highlights several common pain points in data handling, including data entry errors, the need for accuracy, and the time-consuming nature of manual processes. By using Excel to create a clear framework for categorizing breakfast charges based on specific criteria, such as rate codes and meal plan names, the proposed solution offers a glimpse into how businesses can leverage existing tools for enhanced operational efficiency. Such automation can significantly reduce the burden on staff, allowing them to focus on delivering exceptional service rather than being bogged down by administrative tasks. It’s similar to the issues discussed in articles like Expand Cell Styles Ribbon and Charts are black and white, where understanding the fundamentals of Excel can lead to improved outcomes and user experiences.
Moreover, the complexity of the task at hand—such as managing varying data formats across reports and ensuring that seasonal changes in rate codes are easily accommodated—illustrates the importance of adaptability in data management tools. By proposing a settings tab that allows for easy updates to the classification rules, the workbook design not only provides immediate solutions but also anticipates future needs. This kind of forward-thinking is essential in today’s data-driven environment, where the ability to pivot quickly can differentiate between success and stagnation.
As we look towards the future, the implications of this approach extend beyond just the breakfast service in a hotel. It raises important questions about the role of traditional spreadsheet software in modern business operations—will we continue to rely on these legacy tools, or will they evolve to incorporate more advanced functionalities typically seen in dedicated data management systems? Furthermore, as users become more comfortable with automation, we may witness a greater demand for seamless and intuitive solutions that empower them to manage their data without the need for extensive training. The potential for tools like Excel to integrate with emerging technologies could redefine our expectations around data management, making it more accessible and user-friendly.
In conclusion, the endeavor to automate the breakfast briefing process serves as a microcosm of a larger trend in the workplace: the quest for efficiency through automation. As businesses continue to seek ways to optimize operations, the ability to adapt existing tools to meet new challenges will be paramount. How we leverage technology in our day-to-day tasks will likely shape the future of work, inviting us to explore innovative solutions that enhance productivity and streamline processes.
I'm trying to build an Excel workbook that automates our daily breakfast briefing (context: breakfast service in a hotel). The intention is: every morning I paste two system reports into Tab 2 and Tab 3 (one report per tab), and Tab 1 automatically cross-checks the data from both and gives me a clean breakdown for the breakfast team, no manual work.
The two reports I paste each morning
- Tab 2 — Meal Plan report (BJMPGR): room number, guest name, rate code, meal plan name, PAX count
- Tab 3 — In-House Guest report: room number, guest name, rate code, group/company name, reservation note (e.g. "RB" = company covering room & breakfast, "ALL" = all charges covered by company)
What Tab 1 needs to show — four categories
Breakfast included in rate — certain rate codes (BB, MPOBB, WINTER package etc.) always include breakfast. No charge needed.
Company pays — post to folio — reservation note in Tab 3 contains "RB" or "ALL" as a whole word. Charge needs posting to company account.
$24 access — guest pays — meal plan name in Tab 2 contains "Corporate Discounted Breakfast" or similar keywords. Guest pays $24/cover.
Pre-booked — already posted — guest added breakfast themselves. Revenue already in their account. No action needed.
Complications making this tricky
- The WINTER package creates two rows per guest in the meal plan report (breakfast + barista coffee) — the coffee row must be excluded so covers aren't double-counted
- PAX column format is "2 / 0" — needs parsing to extract the number
- Room numbers come through as integers in one report and need to match as text across both via lookup
- Rate codes and meal plan keyword names change seasonally — ideally the rules should be editable from a separate settings tab without touching any formulas
Questions
What's the cleanest way to cross-reference two pasted tables and classify rows based on values from both — XLOOKUP + IF chains, or something better?
For "first match wins" keyword lookup against a settings table, is AGGREGATE(15,6, ROW/ISNUMBER(SEARCH(...))) the right approach, or is there a simpler method?
Would Power Query handle this more cleanly than formulas for a daily paste-and-refresh workflow?
Any thoughts on the overall structure — paste zones in Tabs 2 & 3, hidden logic tab doing the classification, display tab pulling results?
If on Excel 365, would FILTER + SORT be cleaner than AGGREGATE for pulling and sorting rows per category into Tab 1?
[link] [comments]
Read on the original site
Open the publisher's page for the full experience
Related Articles
- Make this convoluted system easier?Basic Excel user here....nothing more than basic formulas. I inherited a convoluted system and am trying to see if there is a better way of doing things than the current manual process. I have a spreadsheet that tracks about 40 different rooms/cabins and which ones are granted access to services (eg: internet, TV, premium TV). Currently we using a spreadsheet with a main tab for all cabins, and then a separate tab for each room/cabin. The main tab basically just tracks the room/cabin, service, and start and stop dates. The info from the main tab are then transferred to the individual room/cabin tab. The tabs are then color coded for whether they should have a service currently turned on/of (green/red) Right now it's all done manually - basically we log in and check each tab to see what needs to be done for the week.......so, open it on Monday, check each tab to see if any need to be turned on.....check on Friday to see what needs to be turned off. Then we go into our other system to actually activate/de-activate services....and change tab color as needed. Is there a way to automate the checking of each tab to see if it falls within the current date (or within a few days) and automatically change the tab color? At least that way we could have a quick and easy visual on which cabins should have service. I'm envisioning something that basically works like this: open the spreadsheet, run something (script, formula, vba ???) that will check each tab - is there anything listed for the current date range (maybe it even prompts for a date range ??), if so turn that tab green. Is there a tab that is currently green but doesn't have anything for the current date? if so, then turn that tab red. Hopefully that all makes sense. I know it seems a bit convoluted and it can be a bit time consuming, especially when multiple people are accessing the sheet and may or may not (usually may not) actually follow the instructions. submitted by /u/GateComfortable1693 [link] [comments]
- What would you do with this task, and how long would it take you to do it?I'm going to describe a situation as specifically as I can. I am curious what people would do in this situation, I worry that I complicate things for myself. I'm describing the whole task as it was described to me and then as I discovered it. Ultimately, I'm here to ask you, what do you do, and how long does it take you to do it? I started a new role this month, I am new to advertising modeling methods like mmm, so I am reading a lot about how to apply the methods specific to mmm in R and python, I use VScode, I don't have a github copilot license, I get to use copilot through windows office license. Although this task did not involve modeling, I do want to ask about that kind of task another day if this goes over well. The task 5, excel sheets are to be provided. You are told that this is a clients data that was given to another party for some other analysis and augmentation. This is a quality assurance task. The previous process was as follows; the data the data structure: 1 workbook per industry for 5 industries 4 workbooks had 1 tab, 1 workbook had 3 tabs each tab had a table that had a date column in days, 2 categorical columns advertising_partner, line_of_business and at least 2 numeric columns per work book. some times data is updated from our side and the partner has to redownload the data and reprocess and share again the process this is done once per client, per quarter (but it's just this client for now) open each workbook navigate to each tab the data is in a "controllable" table bing bing home home impressions spend partner dropdown line of business dropdown where bing and home are controlled with drop down toggles, with a combination of 3-4 categories each. compare with data that is to be downloaded from a tableau dashboard end state: the comparison of the metrics in tableau to the excel tables to ensure that "the numbers are the same" the categories presented map 1 to 1 with the data you have downloaded from tableau aggregate the data in a pivot table, select the matching categories, make sure the values match additional info about the file the summary table is a complicated sumproduct look up table against an extremely wide table hidden to the left. the summary table can start as early as AK and as late as FE. there are 2 broadly different formats of underlying data in the 5 notebooks, with small structure differences between the group of 3. in the group of 3 the structure of this wide table is similar to the summary table with categories in the column headers describing the metric below it. but with additional categories like region, which is the same value for every column header. 1 of these tables has 1 more header category than the other 2 the left most columns have 1 category each, there are 3 date columns for day, quarter. REGION USA USA USA PARTNER bing bing google LOB home home auto impressions spend ...etc date quarter impressions spend ...etc 2023-01-01 q1 1 2 ...etc 2023-01-02 q1 3 4 ...etc in the group of 2 the left most categories are actually the categorical headers in the group of 3, and the metrics, the values in each category mach the dates are now the headers of this very wide table the header labels are separated from the start of the values by 1 column there is an empty row immediately below the final row for column headers. date Label 2023-01-01 2023-01-02 year 2023 2023 quarter q1 q1 blank row REGION PARTNER LOB measure blank row US bing home impressions 1 3 US bing home spend 2 4 US google auto ...etc ...etc ... etc The question is, what do you do, and how long does it take you to do it? I am being honest here, I wrote out this explaination basically in the order in which I was introduced to the information and how I discovered it. (Oh it's easy if it's all the same format even if it's weird, oh there are 2-ish different formatted files) the meeting of this task ended at 11:00AM. I saw this copy paste manual etl project and I simply didn't want to do it. So I outlined my task by identifying the elements of the table, column name ranges, value ranges, stacked / pivoted column ranges, etc... for an R script to extract that data. by passing the ranges of that content to an argument make_clean_table(left_columns="B4:E4", header_dims=c(..etc)) and functions that extract that convert that excel range into the correct position in the table to extract that element. Then the data was transformed to create a tidy long table. the function gets passed once per notebook extracting the data from each worksheet, building a single table with the columns for the workbook industry, the category in the tab, partner, line of business, spend, impressions, etc... IMO; ideally (if I have to check their data in excel that is), I'd like the partner to redo their report so that I received a workbook with the underlying data in a traditionally tabular form and their reporting page to use power query and table references and not cell ranges and formula. submitted by /u/TheTresStateArea [link] [comments]