Thoughts and experience on ML journals [D]
Our take
Recently I’ve been thinking about shifting from conferences to journals due to a few bad experiences with ML conferences reviewing process. The truth is I don’t really have much experience with journals, and I rarely read papers from them.
I don’t really want to submit to something like JMLR because of the extremely long waiting times, and also because my papers tend to be shorter.
From what I understand, TMLR seems like a great choice, but I’m really curious about alternatives. Do you guys have any experience or thoughts on journals like Neurocomputing, Neural Networks, Machine Learning, etc., in terms of how selective they are and overall quality?
They’re all considered Q1, but I’m not really sure what that means in the conference-oriented ML world.
[link] [comments]
Read on the original site
Open the publisher's page for the full experience
Related Articles
- Maths vs machine learning publishing venues [D]I am a research mathematician that has recently written a (in my opinion) pretty neat paper in theoretical computer science that is probably of more interest to machine learning researchers than to fellow mathematicians. I'm therefore seeking to place it in machine learning venues. It's rather long (60 pages) and I have no particular desire to engage with conference culture, so therefore I'm thinking a journal rather than a conference. What are the good journals in ML or CS generally? What I am really looking for is direct comparisons with math journals. I don't really expect people to know this - for example, what is the ML equivalent of Transactions of the AMS? submitted by /u/Agile_Actuary_8246 [link] [comments]
- Does submitting to only journals negatively affect research career after finishing PhD? [D]I saw many discussions about TMLR and other journals lately and how their review processes are considered fairer and less random. My question is, how much does it hurt one's chance much of getting interviewed/hired as a ML research scientist if they choose to publish at only journals like TMLR, JMLR, or Neurocomputing, instead of conferences? Edit: just to clarify, I mean corporate research scientist positions instead of academic positions. submitted by /u/dontknowwhattoplay [link] [comments]
- AI/ML Conferences [D]As a fellow ML researcher, I feel disheartened and discouraged after seeing the experiences of people who submitted their work to ICML 2026. Given the sheer number of papers submitted to A* AI/ML conferences, the current review system does not seem to work well. For example, in some cases, papers are rejected despite the authors addressing all reviewers’ concerns, leading to substantial increases in scores. What could be a better way forward to ensure a fair review process? submitted by /u/msgs008 [link] [comments]
- Anyone submit ML articles to ACM journals (eg. TOPML or TIST)? [D]Have any of you submitted ML articles to ACM journals (eg. TOPML or TIST)? How long did the process take, and were the reviews high-quality? How does it compare to other journals (eg. TMLR) in terms of difficulty? Thanks. submitted by /u/random_sydneysider [link] [comments]