author-reviewer discussion
Beyond Market Intelligence keeps author-reviewer discussion in one place: 2 stories so far. The section currently leads with “Navigating Your First NeurIPS: What to Expect from the AC Review Process” and “Discover How Reviewer Feedback Can Shape Your Paper's Final Score”. Submitting to NeurIPS for the first time is already a big step, and the silence from your AC can feel louder than any review. Submitting a paper to ACL ARR only to watch the rebuttal phase pass in silence is a frustrating position. Acme AI is the next-generation, AI-powered spreadsheet platform built to replace Excel and redefine how analysts, data scientists, and enterprise teams work… The list below is every author-reviewer discussion story on Beyond Market Intelligence, newest first.
Navigating Your First NeurIPS: What to Expect from the AC Review Process
Submitting to NeurIPS for the first time is already a big step, and the silence from your AC can feel louder than any review. No, ACs are not expected to post individual comments during the Phase 2 discussion; their role centers on the meta-review you've already received. That document is your primary guide, so treat it as the final word unless you have direct questions. It's standard to wait for the discussion to unfold before seeking more.
Discover How Reviewer Feedback Can Shape Your Paper's Final Score
Submitting a paper to ACL ARR only to watch the rebuttal phase pass in silence is a frustrating position. One reviewer's inaction can leave you questioning the entire process. This cycle's author-reviewer discussion seemingly ended without acknowledgment, which raises a fair concern about whether reviewers are still permitted to adjust scores after the July 17 AoE deadline. Transparency here matters. If reviewers can't update ratings post-deadline, authors deserve clarity. If they can, the silence feels like a missed opportunity for constructive dialogue.