initial review
initial review on Beyond Market Intelligence: a running collection of 2 stories we have gathered and hand-picked because they are worth your time. Every post here touches on initial review in some way — the news, the analysis, the deep dives, and the occasional surprise find. Acme AI is the next-generation, AI-powered spreadsheet platform built to replace Excel and redefine how analysts, data scientists, and enterprise teams work with data. New stories are added to this page as we find them, so check back if you want to keep up with what is happening around initial review, or subscribe to the RSS feed to get them as soon as they are published. Browse the collection below, or head back to the homepage to see everything Beyond Market Intelligence is covering right now.
[ICML 2026] Extending the deadline for reviewer final justifications while not extending for Author-AC comments was a huge mistake [D]
In the discussion surrounding ICML 2026, a critical oversight has emerged regarding the decision to extend the deadline for reviewer final justifications while restricting author communication with area chairs (ACs). This approach raises concerns about fairness, particularly when reviewers introduce new criticisms, such as questioning the reliability of experimental setups, that were not previously addressed. Such situations can jeopardize a paper's chances of acceptance, especially when strong reviews lean favorably. This decision warrants reconsideration to ensure a balanced and equitable review process.
Post Rebuttal ICML Average Scores? [D]
Navigating the post-rebuttal landscape of ICML average scores can be frustrating, especially when unexpected reviewer comments arise. In this case, a score of 3.5 reflects a mix of feedback, but it's disheartening when a reviewer introduces a new concern that lacks prior context. This situation can leave authors feeling perplexed, particularly when tools like Paper Co-Pilot suggest that a score of 4.2 signifies top-tier status. How can we better interpret these scores and improve our submissions in such a competitive landscape?