rating
Beyond Market Intelligence keeps rating in one place: 3 stories so far. The section currently leads with “Reviewer feedback remains pending as rebuttal process continues”, “Navigating Your First NeurIPS: What to Expect from the AC Review Process”, and “When Reviewers Say Concerns Are Resolved but Don't Update Scores”. Waiting on reviewer feedback is a specific kind of limbo, and it sounds like you are handling it with a clear head. Submitting to NeurIPS for the first time is already a big step, and the silence from your AC can feel louder than any review. Acme AI is the next-generation, AI-powered spreadsheet platform built to replace Excel and redefine how analysts, data scientists, and enterprise teams work… The list below is every rating story on Beyond Market Intelligence, newest first.
Reviewer feedback remains pending as rebuttal process continues
Waiting on reviewer feedback is a specific kind of limbo, and it sounds like you are handling it with a clear head. Your rebuttal is still in motion, and the silence from your reviewers is not a rejection; it is simply part of the process. You have a valid point about the "2" being a limitation you already disclosed, especially when the conference rules discourage that as a weakness.
Navigating Your First NeurIPS: What to Expect from the AC Review Process
Submitting to NeurIPS for the first time is already a big step, and the silence from your AC can feel louder than any review. No, ACs are not expected to post individual comments during the Phase 2 discussion; their role centers on the meta-review you've already received. That document is your primary guide, so treat it as the final word unless you have direct questions. It's standard to wait for the discussion to unfold before seeking more.
When Reviewers Say Concerns Are Resolved but Don't Update Scores
A reviewer saying concerns are resolved without updating the score is a familiar frustration. The 2/4 rating finally moved after a nudge, jumping to 4/2. That aligns with what many observe: score updates often lag behind verbal agreement, but they do happen. The other silent reviewers remain a wildcard. For those waiting, persistence pays off, as this update shows. It is a practical reminder that discussion-phase engagement is uneven, yet a single response can shift the outcome.