The blind review system in academic publishing has a transparency problem, and pretending otherwise undermines the entire peer review process. When reviewers can see authors' names and affiliations, the system is functionally single-blind, not double-blind, and that distinction matters far more than most conferences are willing to admit.
We have seen firsthand how this broken structure enables bias. Student reviewers rejecting other researchers' papers to improve their own acceptance odds is not a hypothetical edge case, it is a documented behavior that erodes trust. Equally concerning is the advantage enjoyed by well-connected research labs with extensive academic networks. If a paper's chances of acceptance depend on who wrote it rather than what it contains, we are no longer evaluating science; we are evaluating reputations. This connects directly to a pattern we explored in Why top AI conferences reject papers before reading them, where systemic shortcuts like desk rejects and reviewer overload create a culture of pre-judgment. When reviewers can see institutional affiliations, that pre-judgment becomes even more insidious, silently tipping the scales before a single result is checked.
The practical consequence for researchers is stark: your work's reception may have less to do with its quality than with the lab you represent or the name attached to the submission. This is not a critique of individual reviewers, most are acting in good faith, but of a system that makes bias easy to exercise and hard to detect. In When a reviewer flags your own prior work as a competitor, we saw how personal knowledge of an author's history can distort review decisions in ways that double-blind review is designed to prevent. The same logic applies here: if a reviewer knows you are from a top-tier university, they may unconsciously lower their standards; if they know you are from an unknown institution, they may raise them. Neither outcome serves science.
What makes this situation particularly frustrating is that the fix is straightforward. True double-blind review, where authors are truly anonymized until after decisions are made, is technically feasible and already practiced by some venues. The reluctance to implement it consistently suggests that the problem is not technical but cultural. Conferences may worry that anonymization makes it harder to catch conflicts of interest or to recognize promising early-career researchers, but those concerns can be addressed through separate disclosure mechanisms without compromising the integrity of the review itself.
One specific detail to watch is whether conferences begin publishing transparency reports that measure how often reviewer recommendations correlate with author reputation or institutional prestige. Until that data is available, the burden remains on individual researchers to advocate for structural changes, and on program chairs to treat anonymity as a requirement, not an option.